Greater Michigan Locals Unite in negotiation Training

---

DTE Energy, a primary energy provider in Michigan, is facing scrutiny over its executive compensation practices, particularly in light of the company's and its customers' recent financial challenges. While customers grapple with rising energy costs and safety issues, DTE's top executives enjoy substantial monetary rewards, raising questions about fairness and corporate responsibility.

In 2022, DTE Energy's CEO, Gerardo Norcia, received a staggering $10,458,218 total Compensation. This figure starkly contrasts the median employee's annual total compensation of $131,133 (which fails to account for the lowest paid union employee rates, which start at $17 per hour in some areas), resulting in a CEO-to-worker pay ratio of 80 to 1. This significant disparity highlights the growing income inequality within the company and raises concerns about prioritizing executive wealth over employee well-being.

The company's executive compensation program, designed to motivate and reward executives for achieving short-term and long-term goals, includes substantial bonuses and stock-based incentives. While these incentives are intended to align executive interests with those of shareholders, critics argue that they prioritize profits over other crucial factors, such as customer affordability and safety.

Recent events have further fueled concerns about DTE's priorities. The company has faced criticism for handling power outages and safety issues. Additionally, customers have been burdened with rising energy costs, making it increasingly difficult for many to afford essential services.

In this context, the lavish compensation packages awarded to DTE's executives have sparked outrage among labor unions and consumer advocacy groups. They argue that the company should prioritize investing in infrastructure improvements, safety measures, and affordable customer rates rather than enriching its top executives.

The controversy surrounding DTE Energy's executive Compensation underscores the need for greater transparency and accountability in corporate governance. As customers and employees continue to face challenges, companies must prioritize the well-being of all stakeholders, not just the financial interests of a select few.

DTE SEC FILINGS BREAKDOWN  

DTE Energy Company posted the first quarter 2024 financial statements for its indirect wholly-owned subsidiary, DTE Gas Company. The financial statements were posted to DTE Energy's website on May 2, 2024. The 8-K also contains forward-looking statements and notes that should be read in conjunction with DTE Energy's 2023 Form 10-K and 2024 Form 10-Q.

Company Earnings (DTE Energy)

• Actual 2024  First Quarter: Net income was $313 million, compared to $445 million for the same period in 2023. This decrease was primarily due to lower earnings in the Energy Trading, Corporate and Other, DTE Vantage, and Gas segments, partially offset by higher earnings in the Electric segment.
• Actual 2023: Net Income Attributable to DTE Energy Company was $1.083 billion, compared to $907 million in 2021. The increase was primarily due to higher earnings in the Electric, Gas, Corporate, and Other segments, partially offset by lower revenues in the DTE Vantage and Energy Trading segments.
• Actual 2021: Net Income Attributable to DTE Energy Company was $907 million, a decrease from $1.368 billion in 2020. This decrease was primarily due to lower earnings in the Corporate and Other segment, driven mainly by losses on the extinguishment of debt incurred in 2021. The decrease was also due to lower earnings in the Energy Trading segment, partially offset by higher revenues in the Electric, Gas, and DTE Vantage segments.

Projected Earnings (DTE Energy)

• DTE Energy has not provided specific projected earnings numbers in the reference documents. However, they have outlined strategic initiatives and expectations for future performance: 
  • Long-term earnings-per-share growth: The company aims to achieve this through a strong balance sheet and an attractive dividend.
  • Capital investments in the utilities are expected to support a modern grid and cleaner energy and drive earnings growth.
  • Carbon emission reduction goals: The company's focus on transitioning from coal-powered energy sources and investing in renewables and natural gas is expected to reduce future operating and fuel costs.
  • Growth in non-utility businesses: DTE Energy anticipates growth opportunities in its DTE Vantage segment, particularly in renewable and custom energy solutions.
  • Operational efficiencies and tax credits: The company expects to benefit from operational efficiencies and tax credits related to the Inflation Reduction Act, which could reduce costs and improve customer affordability.

Operating Costs and Earnings (DTE Energy)

• Actual 2024 First Quarter: Operating revenues were $3.240 billion compared to $3.779 billion for the same period in 2023. Operating expenses were $2.723 billion compared to $3.127 billion for the same period in 2023.
• Actual 2022: Operating revenues were $19.228 billion, compared to $14.964 billion in 2021, and operating expenses were $17.480 billion, compared to $13.469 billion in  2021.
• Actual 2021: Operating revenues were $14.964 billion compared to $11.423 billion in 2020. Operating expenses were $13.469 billion compared to $9.868 billion in 2020.

Executive Compensation (DTE Energy)

A detailed breakdown of each executive compensation package for 2022 is as follows:

Gerardo Norcia (Chairman, President, and CEO):

• Base Salary:  $1,330,769
• Additional  Compensation: $9,127,449 
  • This includes annual incentives, long-term incentives, pension benefits, and other compensation (such as security driver services and limited personal use of corporate assets).
• Total compensation: $10,458,218

David Ruud (Senior Vice President and CFO):

• Base Salary:  $660,769
• Additional compensation: $2,150,949 
  • This includes annual incentives, long-term incentives, and other compensation.
• total compensation: $2,811,718

JoAnn Chavez (Senior Vice President and Chief Legal Officer):

• Base Salary: $596,923
• Additional compensation: $1,890,269 
  • This includes annual incentives, long-term incentives, and other compensation.
• Total compensation: $2,487,192

Trevor F. Lauer (President and COO - DTE Electric):

• Base Salary:  $635,615
• Additional  Compensation: $2,516,553 
  • This includes annual incentives, long-term incentives, and other compensation.
• Total compensation: $3,152,168

Mark W. Stiers (President and COO - DTE Vantage and Energy Trading):

• Base Salary:  $592,385
• Additional compensation: $1,989,166 
  • This includes annual incentives, long-term incentives, and other compensation.
• Total compensation: $2,581,551

Additional compensation, which makes up the majority of each executive's total compensation, is primarily composed of performance-based incentives (annual and long-term) designed to align the executives' interests with those of the shareholders and encourage them to achieve the company's strategic objectives. These incentives are awarded in the form of cash bonuses, stock options, restricted stock, and performance shares, and their value can vary significantly depending on the company's performance and the individual's achievements.

References:

DTE Energy Company (March 13, 2023). Pre 14A

Retrieved from DTE Energy Website https://ir.dteenergy.com/sec-filings/sec-filings-details/default.aspx?FilingId=16486283 

DTE Energy Company (May 4, 2023). Form 8-K 

Retrieved from DTE Energy Website https://ir.dteenergy.com/sec-filings/sec-filings-details/default.aspx?FilingId=16640105 

DTE Energy Company (February 23, 2024). Form 10-K 

Retrieved from DTE Energy Website https://ir.dteenergy.com/sec-filings/sec-filings-details/default.aspx?FilingId=16428500 

DTE Energy Company (April 24, 2024). Form 10-Q 

Retrieved from DTE Energy Website https://ir.dteenergy.com/sec-filings/sec-filings-details/default.aspx?FilingId=17473530